Perspectives
The reasons given for prohibition vary. Legal bans on face-covering clothing are often justified on security grounds, as an anti-
terrorism measure. However, the public controversy is wider, and may be indicative of
polarisation between Muslims and western European societies.
[citation needed]
For some critics, Islamic dress is an issue of
value conflicts and the
Clash of Civilizations. These critics - prominent among them is
Ayaan Hirsi Ali - see Islam as incompatible with
Western values, at least in its present form. They advocate the values of '
Enlightenment liberalism', including
secularism and
equality of women. For them, the burqa or chador are both a symbol of religious
obscurantism and the oppression of women. Western Enlightenment values, in their view, require prohibition, regardless of whether a woman has freely chosen Islamic dress. A more extreme, related view is that freely chosen Islamic dress is a declaration of allegiance to radical
Islamism, and the wearers are enemies of western society, if not terrorists.
Islamic dress is also seen as a symbol of the existence of parallel societies (German:
Parallelgesellschaft), and the failure of
integration: in 2006 British Prime Minister
Tony Blair described it as a "mark of separation".
[5] Visible symbols of a non-western culture conflict with the
national identity in European states, which assumes a shared (non-religious) culture. Proposals for a ban may be linked to other related cultural prohibitions: the Dutch politician
Geert Wilders proposed a ban on
Hijab, on Islamic schools, on new
mosques, and on non-western immigration.
In
France and
Turkey, the emphasis is on the secular nature of the
state, and the symbolic nature of the Islamic dress, and bans apply at state institutions (courts,
civil service) and in state-funded education. These bans also cover Islamic headscarves, which in some other countries are seen as less controversial, although
law court staff in the Netherlands are also forbidden to wear Islamic headscarves on grounds of 'state neutrality'.
An apparently less politicised argument is that in specific professions (teaching), a ban on "veils" (
niqab) is justified, since face-to-face communication and eye contact is required. This argument has featured prominently in
judgments in Britain and the Netherlands, after students or teachers were banned from wearing face-covering clothing.
Public and political response to such prohibition proposals is complex, since by definition they mean that the government decides on individual clothing. Some non-Muslims, who would not be affected by a ban, see it as an issue of
civil liberties, as a
slippery slope leading to further restrictions on private life. A public opinion poll in London showed that 75 percent of Londoners support "the right of all persons to dress in accordance with their religious beliefs".
[6] In another poll in the United Kingdom by
Ipsos MORI, 61 percent agreed that "Muslim women are segregating themselves" by wearing a veil, yet 77 percent thought they should have the right to wear it.
[7]by wiki pedia